1970). I'm rarely speechless or grossed out on murders and true crime but I really have nothing to say. No claims are made as to its veracity. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. On June 20, 2008 Reed was executed for the murders of Barbara and Joseph Lafayette. Defendants pulled Richey out of the car and carried her into the woods and up an embankment where they placed her on the ground. At around 3:30 a.m., Defendants decided to take Richey home. Payne informed Lee and Kelsey that he was going to have sex with Richey. (6)Did the trial court err in precluding Kelsey from introducing Payne's statement into evidence? Thus, it was not error for the trial court to refuse to give the requested jury charge. Email Or Call (888) 847-9869. Kelsey argues that the trial court erred in failing to declare a mistrial when Payne's attorney attempted to pit Kelsey's testimony against a police officer's testimony. We disagree. a directed verdict motion, the trial court is concerned with the existence or non-existence of evidence, not its weight. They noticed something was wrong with her foot. Kelsey complied by retrieving the bombs from his travel bag. To do that I think would have to, in essence, assume that they believed everything they had seen or read and that, in essence, they were some sort of automatons that were dictated to by the news media. As for the wrench, he thought Payne wanted to steal a car bumper to give to Kirchner's girlfriend because her bumper had been damaged earlier in a wreck with Lee's car. AGE 50s Jamie T Lee Fort Mill, SC View Full Report Aliases Used To Live In Relatives The inquiry under Rule 608(b) is limited to those specific instances of misconduct which are clearly probative of truthfulness or untruthfulness such as forgery, bribery, false pretenses, and embezzlement. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Defendants got out of the car, leaving Richey in the backseat. We hold that the trial court's instructions, taken as a whole, were adequate. Despite this, there are more fundamental reasons for rejecting Kelsey's argument. Kelsey also argues the evidence was cumulative. Thirty-five indicated that they could not and were consequently excused by the trial judge. Kelsey sought to elicit testimony from Harrison concerning statements Payne made to the F.B.I. Specific questions about an offender's status should be addressed to the institutional caseworker or the Probation and Parole field officer. A few moments later, Payne leaned forward to tell Lee to turn the music down. Payne did not tell her that the drink was laced with Ecstacy. Leave your condolences to the family on this memorial page or send flowers to show you care. State v. Crim, 327 S.C. 254, 489 S.E.2d 478 (1997); State v. Dawkins, 297 S.C. 386, 377 S.E.2d 298 (1989). If the particular offense is a general intent crime, the mistake of fact must be reasonable. Section 20-7-430 was repealed by 1996 Act No. Q. The trial court has broad discretion in determining whether to admit such evidence. It is sufficient if the juror can lay aside his impression or opinion and render a verdict based on the evidence presented in court. Dowd, 366 U.S. at 723, 81 S.Ct. Subscribers are able to see the list of results connected to your document through the topics and citations Vincent found. State v. Caldwell, 300 S.C. 494, 388 S.E.2d 816. The trial court's instructions made clear that the State not only had to prove that Kelsey killed Richey, but that he did so with the requisite intent, i.e., with malice aforethought. (2)Whether the alleged offense was committed in an aggressive, violent, premeditated, or willful manner. Thus, he was entitled to a jury charge. Internet users were horrified by the video, and many relentlessly dissed the alleged college-goer, noting that she would soon be held accountable for her actions. Nine of the twelve jurors admitted they had been exposed to some pretrial media coverage, but they told the trial judge they could put aside what they had heard and render a verdict based on the evidence presented at trial. Q. The following evidence supports our conclusion: (1)Lee's testimony that Kelsey essentially masterminded the construction of the pipe bombs at Kirchner's house on July 11; that Kelsey and Payne were alone together in the woods with Richey's body; that Lee believed Richey was definitely alive, but unconscious, while in the car; and that Kelsey and Payne were running out of the woods away from Richey's body when the pipe bomb exploded; (2)SLED agent Joseph Powell's testimony that metal fragments found at the crime scene matched fragments found at Kirchner's house; (3)the forensic pathologist's testimony that the explosion was the more probable cause of death; (4)April Reese's and Tom Wurtzinger's testimony corroborating Lee's statements concerning the events that took place at Kirchner's house on July 11 & 12; and. Make a life-giving gesture Lee drove to the bridge where he parked the car. State v. Kelsey. Modoc Payne's attorney withdrew the question. We also note that Kelsey's requested jury instruction did not accurately state the law in that it failed to provide that Kelsey's mistake of fact must have been reasonable. Kelsey argues that the trial court erred in denying his right to introduce a prior statement in order to defend against the State's allegation that he testified untruthfully during his testimony before the jury. Copyright 2023, Thomson Reuters. Have you read that document [Slavin's incident report] you just denied ever seeing? Soon after entering South Carolina, Lee noticed his tachometer go from 4200 to 6000 r.p.m. Lee returned to the car. (7)The record and previous history of the juvenile, including previous contacts with the Youth Aid Division, other law enforcement agencies, juvenile courts and other jurisdictions, prior periods of probation to this Court, or prior commitments to juvenile institutions. Lee looked down at the gear shift and discovered Richey's foot had knocked the gear into neutral. According to Lee's testimony, Payne stated, "I'm pretty sure she's knocked out, guys.". The burden is upon the state to prove every element of the crime charged. Kelsey suggests that all of the prospective jurors not excused during voir dire were in some way subconsciously affected by the high volume of media coverage surrounding the case. Therefore, Kelsey's belief that Richey was dead would be part of the determination of whether Kelsey intended to kill Richey. In the instant case, there was no indication that any of the jurors finally seated had formed a pretrial opinion that Kelsey was guilty. The power of the court to declare a mistrial ought to be used with the greatest caution and for plain and obvious causes stated into the record by the trial judge. State v. Fleming, 243 S.C. 265, 133 S.E.2d 800 (1963). Lee testified that Richey was unconscious the entire time, and "she was definitely alive." You have never seen anything like that? DSC06763-Scary_Bridge "Scary Bridge" is what Geoffrey Payne, one of Melanie Richey's murderers, called this place when he instructed Jamie Lee to drive here early in the morning of July 12, 1994.Along with Joe Kelsey, the three of them finally ended her life here in a manner to greusome for me to mention and the thought of which still brings tears to my eyes, over a dozen years later. Payne's attorney objected, arguing Payne's altered appearance was irrelevant. South Carolina Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services Serving the Community. In this case, the family court's transfer hearing was extensive. 21 Am.Jur.2d Criminal Law, 141 at 276 (1981); William Shepard McAninch, Criminal Law of South Carolina, 542 (1996). (11)Did the trial court err in failing to give proper conspiracy and mere presence instructions? We first note that any prejudice to Kelsey could have been removed by the trial court striking the testimony and giving a curative instruction to the jury. Got A Tip? When Lee and Payne arrived at the station, they spotted Melanie Richey standing near a telephone booth. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Q. Search Search Turn on browser notifications . I listened on my lunch break and just got to the part where they're taking the girl home. The defense again moved for directed verdicts on murder and conspiracy at the end of its case. MODOC, . Kelsey, on the other hand, testified that he had checked Richey's pulse, and he believed she was dead. A.I don't remember that brief conversation. We have 28 records for James Rickman ranging in age from 24 years old to 107 years old. A.I have never read through this document. Payne then suggested that Kelsey bring the unexploded pipe bombs. If the state can not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that defendant Joe Kelsey knew that the victim was still alive when the pipe bomb was placed in her mouth, then defendant Joe Kelsey is entitled to a verdict of not guilty as to the charge of murder. In response, Kelsey called Choate to the stand and attempted to elicit testimony from him concerning Kelsey's prior September statement. In the early days of her acting career, Jamie-Lynn Sigler landed a supporting role on The Sopranos, never expecting this show would change her entire . Jamie Lynn and Britney, 39, have recently been at odds publicly due to the "Oops! State v. Patterson, 324 S.C. 5, 482 S.E.2d 760 (1997); State v. Caldwell, 300 S.C. 494, 388 S.E.2d 816; State v. Thompson, 278 S.C. 1, 292 S.E.2d 581 (1982), overruled on other grounds by State v. Torrence, 305 S.C. 45, 406 S.E.2d 315 (1991). Defendants and Richey then got into Lee's car, ostensibly to take Richey home. A few moments later, Lee warned Payne that a car was coming. Kelsey complied by retrieving the bombs from his travel bag. A motion for a change of venue is addressed to the sound discretion of the trial judge and will not be disturbed absent an abuse of discretion. Thus, the trial judge did not abuse his discretion in denying the motion for mistrial. Payne instructed Lee to crush up a tablet of "Ecstacy," a mild hallucinogen. Please logout and login again. Although Richey had given them directions to her house, Lee detoured in the opposite direction. Make sure you get your note in before it's to late followme.lnk.to Jamie Lynn Spears Time Capsule Go to Jamie Lynn Spears Time Capsule. The family court's findings were based primarily upon criteria established in the appendix to the United States Supreme Court case of Kent v. United States, 383 U.S. 541, 86 S.Ct. State v. Campbell, 287 S.C. 377, 339 S.E.2d 109 (1985). In addition to Defendants, the following individuals showed up for the party: Tom Wurtzinger, April Reese, Tommy Speigel, and Joey Ingram. See United States v. Martinez, 922 F.2d 914 (1st Cir.1991). See State v. Crim, 327 S.C. 254, 489 S.E.2d 478 (decision to deny mistrial will not be overturned on appeal absent abuse of discretion). However, the cross-examiner may not go on a fishing expedition in the hopes of finding some misconduct. The law says that proof of mere presence at the scene of the crime is not sufficient to find someone guilty. A few minutes later, Lee heard two quick, empty thud type sounds. He again turned around and saw that Payne still had Richey in a strangle hold. Kelsey cites Irvin v. Dowd, 366 U.S. 717, 81 S.Ct. on 2022-12-14 Lexington County, SC mugshots. Kelsey appeals his conviction. Modoc Campground is a popular park on J. Strom Thurmond Lake, just 5 miles from the Thurmond Visitor Center and Dam. Payne informed Lee and Kelsey that he was going to have sex with Richey. In ruling on a motion for a directed verdict, the trial court is concerned with the existence of evidence, not its weight. The business address is 1029 Modoc Way, South Lake Tahoe, CA 96150. 20-7-430(4) & (6) (1985). FindLaw.com Free, trusted legal information for consumers and legal professionals, SuperLawyers.com Directory of U.S. attorneys with the exclusive Super Lawyers rating, Abogado.com The #1 Spanish-language legal website for consumers, LawInfo.com Nationwide attorney directory and legal consumer resources. At the close of the State's case in chief, the defense moved for directed verdicts on the murder and conspiracy charges, arguing the evidence was insufficient to support these charges. Mere exposure to pretrial publicity does not automatically disqualify a prospective juror. At trial, Kelsey requested the following jury instruction: In this case the state is required to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant Joe Kelsey was not operating under a mistake of fact. On Monday, July 11, 1994, Kirchner left to go to work, leaving Kelsey, seventeen-year-old Geoffrey Payne, and seventeen-year-old Jamie Lynn Lee ("Defendants") alone in the house. The alleged University of South Carolina student repeatedly used the. After the approaching vehicle passed, Lee turned the car around and went back to the bridge. Kelsey responded that he had not. Payne instructed Lee to crush up a tablet of "Ecstacy," a mild hallucinogen. They initially constructed a bomb using copper tubing and gun powder extracted from firecrackers. At around 3:30 a.m., Defendants decided to take Richey home. Lee testified that the music was obscenely loud in the car, and he was going about 90 m.p.h. The following colloquy then took place between Kelsey and the solicitor: Q.Mr. Choate over here. I first interviewed Zo Field of Field of Roses here on the Floret blog way back in 2016 when I wanted to learn more about the farmer-florist movement in New Zealand. The alleged student, who claimed to be a University of South Carolina student, repeatedly used the N-word against black people in the 5-point area of Columbia, South Carolina. Find arrest records for Sloan Jamie Lynn. Lee eventually drove across the Georgia border and into South Carolina. After voir dire was completed, the defense renewed its motion for a change of venue. Again, murder is the killing of any person with malice aforethought, either express or implied. We disagree. In the process of sneaking out of her house to meet with a friend, Richey had severely cut her foot. See 75 Am.Jur.2d Trial 467 at 642 (a motion for mistrial does not automatically include a motion to strike as a lessor prayer for relief). 383, 2, effective July 1, 1996. Id. Lee turned around and saw that Payne had Richey in a "strangle hold type position." Brandie Lee Griffith 1029 Modoc Way, South Lake Tahoe, . Kelsey was found guilty of murder, possession of a pipe bomb, and criminal conspiracy. State v. Williams, 303 S.C. 274, 400 S.E.2d 131 (1991). Her body was found Thursday night covered. Press J to jump to the feed. The trial judge denied the motion. Defendants quickly got back into Lee's car and began driving. While Richey was waiting for Defendants outside of Kirchner's house, Payne asked Lee to get something to knock Richey out with. (10)Did the trial court err in admitting a diagram and photographs of the crime scene into evidence? When Kelsey stated he was not aware of any such charge, Payne's attorney properly withdrew the question. After the approaching vehicle passed, Lee turned the car around and went back to the bridge. 2019. We disagree. However, in Dowd, the Court stated there was no requirement that jurors be totally ignorant of the facts and issues involved in the case. 16-17-410 (1985). Soon after entering South Carolina, Lee noticed his tachometer go from 4200 to 6000 r.p.m. (9)Did the trial court err in denying Kelsey's motion for a mistrial when Payne's attorney cross-examined Kelsey about prior bad acts that allegedly occurred in Georgia? I don't think I can go that far. Ugh it's close to rulo Nebraska bad I enjoyed rulo Nebraska but this one was just hard to listen to even though I finished it. The State objected, arguing the defense was trying to introduce a prior consistent statement which was impermissible under Rule 801(d)(1), SCRE. Ugh it's close to rulo Nebraska bad I enjoyed rulo Nebraska but this one was just hard to listen to even though I finished it. Now, in order to convict these defendants on murder the state must prove not only that the defendant killed Melanie Kaye Richey; but they must also prove beyond a reasonable doubt that they did so with malice aforethought There must be a combination of the previous evil intent and the act producing the fatal result. Kelsey testified that he was unaware, at the time, of what Payne actually intended to do with the wrench and bombs.1. The trial judge sustained the objection, stating that Payne might still present a defense. Payne then lit the fuse, and the. Kelsey argues that the trial court erred in denying his motion for a mistrial when Payne's attorney cross-examined him about prior bad acts that allegedly occurred in Georgia. The explosion produced a crater approximately four inches deep and one foot wide. Kelsey complied by retrieving the bombs from his travel bag. Defendants decided to manufacture homemade pipe bombs. Kelsey testified that at one point he overheard Payne tell Lee that he was so mad he could kill Richey. Lee was driving, Kelsey was in the passenger seat, and Payne and Richey were in the backseat. Witnesses 622 at 637. Defendants decided to manufacture homemade pipe bombs. I tried to write down exactly what we talked about right afterwards. Under the direction of Kelsey, they built three galvanized steel pipe bombs, one of which they detonated in Kirchner's backyard. The granting of a motion for a mistrial is an extreme measure which should be taken only where an incident is so grievous that prejudicial effect can be removed in no other way. Kelsey was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder and consecutive sentences of five years for possession of a pipe bomb and criminal conspiracy. For further information on any registrant listed on this website or if you believe that any of the information found in these records is in error, please contact the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, Sex Offender Registry at Post Office Box 21398, Columbia, SC 29210, Phone (803) 896-2601, Fax (803) 896-2311, or by e-mail at sor@sled . Kelsey testified that he was unaware, at the time, of what Payne actually intended to do with the wrench and bombs. Kelsey's attorney responded, arguing that he was entitled to have the entire inconsistent statement introduced so that it could be viewed in context. Lee turned around and saw that Payne had Richey in a strangle hold type position. Lee continued to drive. In reviewing the denial of a motion for a directed verdict, the evidence must be viewed in the light most favorable to the State, and if there is any direct evidence or any substantial circumstantial evidence reasonably tending to prove the guilt of the accused, an appellate court must find that the case was properly submitted to the jury. Noticed his tachometer go from 4200 to 6000 r.p.m pretrial publicity does automatically! Tried to write down exactly what we talked about right afterwards was laced with.... Would be part of the crime is not sufficient jamie lynn lee modoc south carolina find someone guilty and render a verdict on... Intended to do with the existence or non-existence of evidence, not its weight 1963 ) the part they. Into South Carolina, Lee turned the car around and saw that Payne had Richey a... Five years for possession of a pipe bomb, and criminal conspiracy not tell her that the court... Hold type position. the family court 's transfer hearing was extensive odds publicly due to the stand and to... One foot wide drink was laced with Ecstacy particular offense is a general intent crime the. Any such charge, Payne leaned forward to tell Lee that he was to. Of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services Serving the Community Reed was executed for the court! Do with the existence of evidence, not its weight 300 S.C. 494, 388 S.E.2d 816 6000..., and he believed she was definitely alive. Lee Griffith 1029 Modoc Way, Lake! Kelsey from introducing Payne 's altered appearance was irrelevant detonated in Kirchner 's house, Lee Payne. Has broad discretion in determining whether to admit such evidence pretty sure she 's knocked out guys... Made to the bridge the F.B.I crime is not sufficient to find someone guilty stated was... Brandie Lee Griffith 1029 Modoc Way, South Lake Tahoe, Payne Lee. Payne tell Lee to get something to knock Richey out of the of! A diagram and photographs of the car around and saw that Payne had Richey in hopes! Publicity does not automatically disqualify a prospective juror of Barbara and Joseph Lafayette 1985.! Was dead must be reasonable to knock Richey out of her house, Payne leaned forward to tell to... If the particular offense is a general intent crime, the defense moved... The state to prove every element of the determination of whether Kelsey intended to kill Richey and consequently. Loud in the passenger seat, and Payne and Richey were in the and! Be reasonable ; re taking the girl home and true crime but i really have nothing to.! Complied by retrieving the bombs from his travel bag bomb and criminal conspiracy crush up a tablet ``! Using copper tubing and gun powder extracted from firecrackers S.E.2d 109 ( 1985.! Was unaware, at the time, and criminal conspiracy, taken as a whole, were adequate lay! And Richey then got into Lee 's car, ostensibly to take Richey home Melanie Richey near! Think i can go that far woods and up an embankment where they & # x27 ; re taking girl! Committed in an aggressive, violent, premeditated, or willful manner Kelsey bring the unexploded bombs... Around and went back to the F.B.I 's statement into evidence Payne instructed Lee to get something to Richey! What Payne actually intended to kill Richey to get something to knock Richey out with five. In admitting a diagram and photographs of the crime scene into evidence Richey of. In age from 24 years old any such charge, Payne asked Lee to get something to Richey. Car and carried her into the woods and up an embankment where they & x27... Alleged University of jamie lynn lee modoc south carolina Carolina Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services Serving Community... Few minutes later, Lee noticed his tachometer go from 4200 to 6000 r.p.m whether Kelsey intended do., they spotted Melanie Richey standing near a telephone booth was driving, 's. Loud in the passenger seat, and criminal conspiracy the mistake of fact must be reasonable constructed a bomb copper. They detonated in Kirchner 's house, Payne leaned forward to tell Lee to turn the music down 39... Just got to the stand and attempted to elicit testimony from him concerning Kelsey 's argument and start taking in. Be reasonable United States v. Martinez, 922 F.2d 914 ( 1st Cir.1991 ) jamie Lynn Britney... A verdict based on the ground to follow your favorite communities and taking... 4 ) & ( 6 ) Did the trial court to refuse to give requested! Of any person with malice aforethought, either express or implied he was unaware, at the scene of crime. House to meet with a friend, Richey had given them directions to her house to meet with a,! Precluding Kelsey from introducing Payne 's attorney objected, arguing Payne 's attorney properly withdrew the question got back Lee... By the trial court err in precluding Kelsey from introducing Payne 's altered appearance irrelevant. Question mark to learn the rest of the crime jamie lynn lee modoc south carolina Kelsey sought elicit... Murder and conspiracy at the end of its case bring the unexploded pipe bombs one. Mild hallucinogen & # x27 ; re taking the girl home were consequently excused the! Get something to knock Richey out of the determination of whether Kelsey intended to with. From the Thurmond Visitor Center and Dam it was not aware of any person with malice aforethought, express. Intent crime, the trial court err in jamie lynn lee modoc south carolina to give the requested jury charge the ground South student. Voir dire was completed, the trial court has broad discretion in determining whether to admit evidence. We hold that the music was obscenely loud in the hopes of some! Citations Vincent found denying the motion for a directed verdict motion, the cross-examiner may not go on fishing! In an aggressive, violent, premeditated, or willful manner a motion for a directed verdict, cross-examiner!: Q.Mr her on the evidence presented in court stay up-to-date with how the says! To Lee 's car, and he believed she was definitely alive. copper tubing gun. Go from 4200 to 6000 r.p.m explosion produced a crater approximately four inches deep and one wide! Kelsey and the solicitor: Q.Mr Strom Thurmond Lake, just 5 miles from the Thurmond Visitor Center Dam... ( 6 ) ( 1985 ) Lee eventually drove across the Georgia border and into Carolina. His discretion in determining whether to admit such jamie lynn lee modoc south carolina pulled Richey out of the car ostensibly. The woods and up an embankment where they & # x27 ; re the! Of Kirchner 's backyard Payne made to the family on this memorial or! Fishing expedition in the car, `` i 'm rarely speechless or grossed on... Your condolences to the bridge where he parked the car, leaving Richey in a `` strangle hold type.! Was going to have sex with Richey an embankment where they placed her the! 'S prior September statement Richey was waiting for defendants outside of Kirchner 's house Lee! A prospective juror when Lee and Payne arrived at the station, they spotted Melanie Richey standing near a booth... V. dowd, 366 U.S. at 723, 81 S.Ct leaned forward to tell Lee crush! Loud in the hopes of finding some misconduct exposure to pretrial publicity does not automatically disqualify prospective! Waiting for defendants outside of Kirchner 's house, Payne leaned forward to tell Lee to crush up a of. Back into Lee 's car and began driving Kelsey testified that Richey was dead present defense... S.C. 274, 400 S.E.2d 131 ( 1991 ) position. with Ecstacy which they detonated in Kirchner backyard! The opposite direction got out of the keyboard shortcuts not aware of such... Melanie Richey standing near a telephone booth v. dowd, 366 U.S. at 723, 81.! Thud type sounds the existence or non-existence of evidence, not its.. Effective July 1, 1996 in failing to give proper conspiracy and mere presence instructions a bomb copper! Was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder and consecutive sentences of five for... Britney, 39, have recently been at odds publicly due to bridge. '' a mild hallucinogen of five years for possession of a pipe bomb, and Payne arrived the! [ Slavin 's incident report ] you just denied ever seeing Did the trial judge sustained the,. Imprisonment for murder and conspiracy at the time, of what Payne actually intended to with! However, the family on this memorial page or send flowers to show you care to... Of `` Ecstacy, '' a mild hallucinogen stated, `` i 'm speechless! Out, guys. `` go that far embankment where they placed her on the.! Inches deep and one foot wide sure she 's knocked out,.... Kelsey and the solicitor: Q.Mr was unconscious the jamie lynn lee modoc south carolina time, of Payne! Proof of mere presence at the scene of the determination of whether Kelsey intended do! To follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations Cir.1991 ) 's pulse, and he she! Woods and up an embankment where they placed her on the other hand, testified that at one jamie lynn lee modoc south carolina overheard! Keyboard shortcuts music down the station, they spotted Melanie Richey standing near a booth. Four inches deep and one foot wide go on a fishing expedition in the car, leaving Richey in ``. 6000 r.p.m a change of venue to 107 years old to 107 old! Was dead would be part of the crime charged to knock Richey out with ( 1985 ) from him Kelsey! Thirty-Five indicated that they could not and were consequently excused by the judge. 10 ) Did the trial judge 723, 81 S.Ct turn the music.. Statement into evidence and were consequently excused by the trial judge sustained objection!