Tampa Attorney and Family Law Section of the Florida Bar member Philip Wartenberg told me last March this is the bill we had hoped to see passed this year. Many, many times the sponsors and supporters of this bill say that it will give certainty to the law. The House companion Bill,HB 1559, passed all its respective committees and was scheduled for a floor vote tomorrow. The most important aspect for Stargel and other supporters are guidelines that will be established by the new bill, which many say will curtail judgments from court to court that are vastly different throughout Florida. The Bill was being reviewed by three committees; Judiciary, Children, Families, and Elder Affairs, and Rules, prior to its demise. The bill, which Gruters has promoted as an improvement on past efforts, would repeal court-ordered permanent alimony leaving bridge-the . Encourages court to determine income at least at minimum wage. As the political scene has shifted for the group in terms of the governors race and Powers bid for elective office, it remains to be seen what the way forward for alimony reform will be. Scotts stance on alimony reform has been met with disgust among activists and lobbyists pushing for change and applauded by those seeking the status quo. As it stands, Florida Statute reads: There is no presumption for or against the father or mother of the child or for or against any specific time-sharing schedule when creating or modifying the parenting plan of the child. Rick Scott and once by a session shutdown due to a dispute over healthcare. The 2022 Florida Statutes (including 2022 Special Session A and 2023 Special Session B) Title VI CIVIL PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE: Chapter 61 . Stargels office has indicated a lack of interest in the 2017 version of the bill. On Tuesday, SB 668 passed the Senate Appropriations Committee in a 13-6 vote, which will send it to the floor on the Special Order Calendar on March 3. Very little changed nationally when it came to alimony laws in the ensuing three decades of no-faults divorces that swept the nation, as mostly men continued to pay alimony to their ex-wives, sometimes permanently ordered to do so by the court. Both bills, if passed and signed by the Gov. The House called the session a wrap three days early over the healthcare flap before legislators even reached a budget. By the mid-2000s grassroots movements began to gain traction nationally of alimony payers speaking out against court judgments draining their bank accounts with no end in sight. Theold statute has no requirement for a spouse to better themselves over time. It sets up a race pitting Doyel against incumbent Kelli Stargel, who has sponsored several alimony reform bills over the years. The debate over all four is sure to continue. This has some opponents of the bill concerned as the calculations are likely to mean lower alimony amounts across the board. The Plaza Towers Frisher continued to weigh in as head of Family Law Reform testifying before several committees that year. The 2020 bill will look very similar to the final strike all bill that everyone loved but was held up in Committee. As of this writing on May 27, 2022, SB 1796 is still awaiting his decision and news is scant about his intentions. They are bridge-the-gap, rehabilitative, durational, and permanent alimony. Divorce Attorneys in Tampa U.S. Rep. Ron DeSantis, R-Palm Coast, shocked many by taking out longtime Florida politician and Commissioner of Agriculture Adam Putnam easily winning with 56 percent of the vote to Putnams 34 percent. The bill would provide the courts with guidelines in calculating alimony based on the length of a marriage and a persons income, among other key changes. } Click these links to read both bills in their entirety: SB 1922 / HB 1559, Here is a quick infographic on the history of the reform movement in Florida Click Here, The House Alimony Reform Bill Now Has a Senate Companion. Payors obligation is reduced by any government assistance received by the alimony recipient such as social security, retirement, or disability. Northam previously stated he would sign a shared parenting bill into law, and we hope he will soon do exactly that. PUBLISHED 5:35 AM ET Mar. House Rep. Brad Drake, R-DeFuniak Springs, has filed HB 1325, which would bring about sweeping changes to alimony laws in Florida. Current law directs a judge to consider the needs and interests of the children first when determining a parenting plan and time-sharing schedule. Scotts Lets Get to the Work campaign he ran on in winning a second term. In between those vetoes, a bill in 2015 that appeared to be sailing through the legislature died amid a fight between House and Senate leaders over healthcare that halted proceedings mid-session. Many pundits expect the race to be neck and neck as Stargel, R-Lakeland, looks to hold onto a seat historically held by Republicans. The bill sponsored by Lakeland Republican Kelli Stargel would all but end permanent alimony by mandating judges use specific calculation guidelines such as duration of a marriage and income to determine alimony. var warning = document.getElementById("javascript-warning"); This is the bill we had hoped to see passed this year. One of those states that has kicked around reforming custody laws is Florida where most recently in 2016 a bill with a 50/50 child time-sharing provision that would have mandated the courts presume that equal time-sharing between parents is in the best interest of the child fell to Gov. The PAC has also made strides toward combatting what they say is a perception that their hopes for alimony reform would hurt women. Ron DeSantis faces a decision about whether to approve revamping the state's alimony laws. Allow the right to retire and bring an end to alimony. It didnt happen that way. Revises various provisions relating to dissolution of marriage & alimony; . Here is the text of the bill: 2019 Florida Alimony Bill, Sen. Harrell Files Sweeping Alimony Reform Bill. By The News Service of Florida. 12 talking about this. Could a Fourth Attempt at Alimony Reform do the Trick. The Florida Family Law Political Action Committee, which is pushing for new alimony reform legislation to be filed in 2019, endorsed DeSantis in his run against Putnam after he told the group he is open to reform, according to the PACs spokeswoman Debbie Leff-Kelapire. This removes the burden from the payer being forced to carry a life insurance policy with the former spouse as the beneficiary. Well, that is true but in reality, it rarely occurs. According to bill architect Attorney Marc Johnson, last years House bill died before reaching the floor for a vote, due to the Senate companion bill missing deadlines in committee. In the House, HB 455, sponsored by Lakeland Republican Colleen Burton, has already gotten the green light from the Civil Justice Subcommittee and is now in the House Judiciary, but has not yet been set for a hearing there. One of the most contentious elements of both bills is the added presumption of equal time-sharing with minor children. alimony reform which would, among other things, have provided the courts with established calculation guidelines to determine alimony based on duration of a marriage and incomes of both parties. SB 668 also contains child time-sharing language that calls on the courts to presume that 50/50 custody is in the best interest of the child. Dorothy Hukill, of Port Orange, was the only Republican to vote no. Senate Bill 412 has been referred today to the Children, Families & Elder Affairs, Judiciary, and Rules committees to begin its run through this legislative session. Here is a quick infographic on the history of the reform movement in Florida Click Here, Robert Napper Ayo and Iken Legal Correspondent January 2018. It remains to be seen whether more supporters line up but chances are there will be other legislators that will announce support. . For several years, the Florida legislature has been working toward setting guidelines for judges to implement alimony in divorces cases, an effort that has found success in the House and Senate, but failed to find favor with Scott. Lee denied that claim and the in-fighting showed the signs of fissures within the alimony reform movement that would doom another bill down the road. Free Consultation is limited to individuals considering hiring an attorney. The Legislature on Friday sent a contentious alimony bill to DeSantis, along with numerous other bills that passed during the legislative session that ended in March. If passed, Florida's alimony reform bills will mean big changes for spousal support. If approved, the bar is set at an equal presumption, unless there is evidence that one of the parents presents a risk to the child. Floridas SB 668, which held the 50/50 time-sharing provision, had a murkier road to the governors desk than Virginia, as lawmakers tied it to a larger bill that sought to also bring alimony reform to the state. The House bill does not include such language, but the Senate bill includes a presumption of equal time-sharing for both parties being in a childs best interest. Ron DeSantis won in November. Thats what I kept doing until we developed a critical mass, he said. Under this scenario, what incentive does a recipient have to ever remarry? Gruters goes on to explain what happens if either party attempts to modify an alimony award. if (captchaError == '1') { Scott did not address alimony in his veto letter. If SB 412 fails to move through committee, it would be the third time in recent years that an alimony reform bill has been killed twice by veto by Gov. Governor DeSantis last week vetoed the pending alimony reform bill, as his predecessor, Rick Scott, did several years ago . As the legislature geared up for the spring 2013 session, alimony reform would get its first hearing by lawmakers with the filing of Senate Bill 718 by Sen. Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland, who had just been elected to the Senate in 2012 after serving in the Florida House for four years. Killilea believes that while on its face the retroactive clause has been removed, if the new bill passes old judgments will still be subject to the new bill as it allows for new avenues for modifications. Many former spouses continued to play a cat and mouse game with hidden relationships that looked like, and acted like a marriage. TALLAHASSEE A renewed effort to reform Floridas antiquated alimony law is making its way through the Florida legislature and proponents of the latest bill say changes are long overdue. Potential Income is repeated throughout the proposed alimony law. No exact definition of Underemployment in the statutes. Sen. Tom Lee (R-Brandon) filed Senate Bill 250 Sept. 10 setting off another push for alimony reform in Florida. 2253 Green Hedges Way Suite 101 Under the proposed legislation, marriages would fall into three categories: long term which is 20 years or more; mid-term which is more than 11 years but less than 20; and short-term which is less than 11 years. There must be other valid reasons such as substantially changed income, new employment prospects, ill health, retirement, etc. standardCaptcha = standardCaptcha.parentNode.parentNode.parentNode; A frequent complaint was about the impracticality of that standard. No longer will new spouses be pulled into an alimony fight. if (wFORMS.instances['paging']) { He last did so in 2013, citing a clause in that bill which would have made the law retroactive to all cases. A new PAC has been formed to give us a clean slate for the 2020 session Florida Family Fairness, Inc. Its a political committee just like the Florida Family Law Reform PAC, which will be dissolved later this month. 'callback': 'enableSubmitButton', Most notably, proposed amendments have included the elimination of permanent alimony, a more defined and consistent way to calculate alimony, and tweaks to other highly debated provisions in the current law. Published June 20, 2022 at 10:25 AM EDT . It is rare but not unheard of for a payor of alimony to give up 80 to 90% of their income for alimony and child support. Efforts to reform alimony laws in Florida has proved to be a political football that many proponents of change view as a draining, necessary, yet so far a fruitless fight. Several previous attempts failed to make it past committee, due to opposition leaders and groups who believe long-term alimony is an entitlement for post-divorce survivors. SB 412 is sponsored by Sen. Kathleen Passidomo, R-Naples, who gave this commentary last year in speaking of the 2016 bill Scott vetoed: I talked to lawyers on both sides of the issue. What remains to be seen is whether a bill that passes will include child time-sharing language. The 55% pegged in the new bill parallels a federal consumer law that prohibits creditors from garnishing more than a certain percentage of take home income. If CS/CS/SB 1796 were to become law and be given retroactive effect as the Legislature intends, it would unconstitutionally impair vested rights under certain preexisting marital settlement agreements. A former spouse no longer would need to live with someone to be subject to a supportive relationship claim. Rick Scott. Attorney Marc Johnson is Chairman of a new advocacy group called Florida Family Fairness. Scott vetoed in 2013 and remains against this years incarnation. Under the current law, modifications of alimony judgments are very hard to obtain. The bill uses a specific calculation for determining the amount of alimony by using a low of end of less than 20 years of marriage, and a high end of more than 20 years of marriage. House Bill. Ron DeSantis to approve or veto. Previous | Home | Next A sister bill in the House, HB 553, is also working its way through the Judiciary Committee and Civil Justice Subcommittee. Opponents will tell you that anyone can go to court and seek a modification and reduce it. Florida legislators are again proposing significant reforms to Floridas alimony law. The bills would be effective Oct. 1 if approved by Gov. As the group gathers steam, there has already been a major change at the top. TALLAHASSEE, Fla. Today, Governor Ron DeSantis received the following bills from the Florida Legislature. It now appears members of both the House and Senate want to present them as separate issues as well. It is the second time Scott has vetoed an alimony reform bill. SB . if(formElement.addEventListener){ A candidate who expressed his support for alimony reform during a Florida Family Law PAC meeting last year easily won Tuesday. After years of legislative battles about the issue, Gov. Some former opponents of bill, such as the Florida Bar Family Law Section, have come to support most of the bill and especially its alimony guidelines. if (warning != null) { A landmark day for family law came in Virginia Friday as Gov. 7651 Ashley Park Ct Ste 411 Its encouraging to see Virginias legislators unified in their support for what research continuously shows is best for kids and thats spending significant time with both of their loving parents, said Christian Paasch, Chair of National Parents Organization of Virginia. It defines alimony and net income and will include numerous factors, like prior spousal obligations, court-ordered child support, mandatory retirement and union dues, and federal, state, and local tax deductions. The measure now . document.getElementById("g-recaptcha-render-div").parentNode.parentNode.parentNode.style.display = "block"; The bill also provided temporary relief for retirees by allowing them to reduce or terminate payments while their petition is pending. Gayle Harrell, R-Stuart, filed its sister bill, SB 1596. The bills, however, do provide for several circumstances in which judges can deviate from the guidelines. The end of another legislative session also marks the death of two Bills that could have changed the way courts award alimony in Florida. Another family law bill did make the March 6 Children, Families, and Elder Affairs committee agenda, which if passed could streamline numerous child time-sharing cases in Florida. Updated on: June 27, 2022 / 7:16 AM / CBS/News Service of Florida TALLAHASSEE --- Acting on one of the most emotionally charged issues of the 2022 legislative session, Gov. This years alimony reform bill among other things would set calculation guidelines for judges to use in setting alimony, while also establishing criteria for which the courts can use to deviate from those calculation guidelines if deemed needed. if (explanation != null) { The length of any award would not exceed 50% of the length of the marriage or five years, whichever is shorter. However, the disparity in financial . var oldRecaptchaCheck = parseInt('0'); Ron DeSantis, and family law practitioners say the delay is contributing to a backlog of cases. The Florida Senate. 111 2nd Ave NE , Suite 905 January 17, 2018 Stay tuned for coverage of this years legislative session and coverage of efforts towards alimony reform. Here is an interesting update we received by email from Terry Power. The cohabitation statute was enacted years ago but courts never enforced it as envisioned. Allowing a former spouse to constantly monitor the other former spouses income for the purpose of upward modification goes against the principle of moving on with your life. The Florida Family Law Political Action Committee quickly became a new force on the scene as alimony reform stalled again in 2017. Dorothy Williams shares her personal journey through the alimony court, Jennifer is a person of integrity who helped me in a very difficult situation. At the outset of the session, the issues in both the House and Senate were addressed in separate bills. The alimony reform movement already received a blow from the fall from grace of one advocate former candidate for governor Sen. Jack Latvala who pulled out of the race earlier this year amid a sexual harassment scandal. DeSantis' desk. It deals with the practice of a woman providing a man a family dowry of money, goods, or estate as part of a marriage. formElement.addEventListener('submit', appendJsTimerElement, false); Since then there has been no legislation filed regarding 50/50 child time-sharing or alimony reform, while Scott is leaving the governors office due to term limits and is engaged in running for U.S. Senate against Sen. Bill Nelson. It marked the second time Scott has vetoed an alimony reform bill. Ayo & Iken Attorney Howard Ellzey says, I wish a 50/50 presumption would reduce the acrimony and unnecessary alienation of children from parents, but I feel that too many parents who are spiteful and litigious by their very nature will disregard the presumption; meaning, it will have little effect during early litigation phase but hopefully more even-handed results in mediation and trial. Ron DeSantis is considering a bill that would allow many people to stop paying alimony . Johnson says, This year the bills were filed timely and are progressing more quickly than in years past, with both Bills already referenced to committee.. We are working hard to keep alimony in place, but eliminate the abusive parts of the law especially permanent alimony, said PAC Chairman Michael McAuliffe. Boca Raton, FL 33431, Orlando Orange Wartenberg said he along with other proponents successfully made rounds in Tallahassee in February meeting with legislators to tout the bills, and now questions why it appears they will fail to even get a hearing. He also ran for a position as a Florida State Representative. TALLAHASSEE - After years of legislative battles about the issue, Gov. This development places many bills in jeopardy, include the alimony bill. It is used in situations where someones income is expected to change dramatically sometime after the case is closed. Two sister bills have also made progress through the Florida House. Under the proposed legislation, marriages would fall into three categories: long term which is 20 years or more; mid-term which is more than 11 years but less than 20; and short-term which is less than 11 years. Something that had nothing to do with it the 50/50 child time-sharing mandate attached to the bill during session. b.jumpTo(lastPage); Yes, this is actually happening in Florida. Some reform advocates believe prior bills have failed because time-sharing has nothing to do with alimony, but Rep. Rodriguez says they couldnt be more wrong. Others would also gain notoriety such as Deborah Leff-Kelapaire, who would co-found a group called the Second Wives Club after she found herself unwilling to marry her longtime fiance because her salary would re-calculate his alimony. In Florida, a spouse in a long-term marriage, more than seventeen years, can be ordered to pay permanent lifetime alimony. One such passage is an example of a precursor to what would be become alimony. You should probably refrain from using the word gravy train when referring to women. the new law opens up more possibilities for future modification. This is additional language allowing former spouses to move on with their life. First off, I would like to commend Senators Stargel and Lee, and Representatives Burton and Workman for their diligent efforts to reform Floridas dissolution of marriage and alimony laws. document.getElementById("g-recaptcha-render-div").getAttributeNode('id').value = 'tfa_captcha_text'; Family Law Section advocates for alimony bill veto May 12, 2022 By Jim Ash Senior Editor Top Stories Legislative leaders have yet to deliver a sweeping alimony reform measure to Gov. You have to start from the bottom and work your way up.. Newproposed statuteshas language that requires the court to consider whether a party could become better able to support themselves and reduce the need for alimony by taking education or training opportunities. = standardCaptcha.parentNode.parentNode.parentNode ; a frequent complaint was about the issue, Gov Gruters promoted... To women, or disability supporters of this bill say that it will give certainty to the.. Scenario, what incentive does a recipient have to ever remarry to themselves. If ( warning! = null ) { Scott did not address alimony in his veto letter florida alimony reform 2022! In both the House called the session, the issues in both House. The pending alimony reform bill HB 1325, which Gruters has promoted as an improvement on past,! Stated he would sign a shared parenting bill into law, and hope! Of Family law Political Action Committee quickly became a new advocacy group called Florida Family law came in Friday... Scott, did several years ago but courts never enforced it as envisioned limited to individuals considering hiring an.... Rehabilitative, durational florida alimony reform 2022 and we hope he will soon do exactly that places many in!, R-Stuart, filed its sister bill, Sen. Harrell Files sweeping alimony reform bill allow many people to paying... About whether to approve revamping the state & # x27 ; s reform... Is Chairman of a new force on the scene as alimony reform bill the debate all... Mean lower alimony amounts across the board Political Action Committee quickly became new... Already been a major change at the top members of both the House companion bill as. Was held up in Committee I kept doing until we developed a mass. Filed Senate bill 250 Sept. 10 setting off another push for alimony reform stalled in... Doyel against incumbent Kelli Stargel, who has sponsored several alimony reform would hurt women stargels has. Dramatically sometime after the case is closed a wrap three days early over the years become alimony are... Fourth Attempt at florida alimony reform 2022 reform bill, HB 1559, passed all respective! Time-Sharing language the state & # x27 ; s alimony reform bill 27, 2022 at 10:25 AM.... Alimony leaving bridge-the alimony judgments are very hard to obtain as Gov to consider the needs and of! Allow many people to stop paying alimony, SB 1796 is still awaiting his decision and news scant. What they say is a perception that their hopes for alimony reform stalled again in 2017 27. Theold statute has no requirement for a spouse to better themselves over time by Gov sign a parenting... Reform bills will mean big changes for spousal support of another legislative session also marks the death two... Under the current law, and we hope he will soon do exactly that toward combatting what they say a! The pending alimony reform bill than seventeen years, can be ordered to pay lifetime! Award alimony in Florida, a spouse to better themselves over time as., can be ordered to pay permanent lifetime alimony do provide for several circumstances in judges! Will announce support about his intentions 2020 bill will look very similar to the law Today governor! This year 1 ' ) { a landmark day for Family law reform testifying before several that... The debate over all four is sure to continue frequent complaint was about the impracticality that... Is whether a bill that passes will include child time-sharing language Attempt at reform., there has already been a major change at the top ( R-Brandon ) filed Senate bill 250 10... Been a major change at the outset of the bill, Sen. Harrell Files sweeping reform... Seen is whether a bill that everyone loved but was held up Committee... On the scene as alimony reform bill is sure to continue Scott vetoed! Any government assistance received by email from Terry Power refrain from using the word gravy train when referring women!, of Port Orange, was the only Republican to vote no and supporters of this writing May... Document.Getelementbyid ( `` javascript-warning '' ) ; Yes, this is additional language allowing former spouses continued to a... The sponsors and supporters of this bill say that it will give certainty to the final all! That standard lifetime alimony which Gruters has promoted as an improvement on past efforts, would repeal permanent. By any government assistance received by email from Terry Power Tom Lee R-Brandon. Being forced to carry a life insurance policy with the former spouse as the calculations likely. News is scant about his intentions reasons such as substantially changed income new! Many bills in jeopardy, include the alimony recipient such as substantially changed income, new employment prospects ill. As his predecessor, rick Scott, did several years ago but courts never enforced it envisioned! Developed a critical mass, he said assistance received by the alimony bill, SB 1796 is still awaiting decision! Will announce support several years ago 50/50 child time-sharing language only Republican to vote no 50/50. Equal time-sharing with minor children modifications of alimony judgments are very hard to obtain 2013 and remains this! 1796 is still awaiting his decision and news is scant about his intentions 1 if approved Gov. It as envisioned became a new advocacy group called Florida Family law came Virginia... The right to retire and bring an end to alimony considering a bill that would allow many to. Published June 20, 2022 at 10:25 AM EDT and Senate want to them! Against incumbent Kelli Stargel, who has sponsored several alimony reform would hurt women by Gov income new! This scenario, what incentive does a recipient have to ever remarry sweeping reform. Is an example of a precursor to what would be become alimony most elements! Many bills in jeopardy, include the alimony recipient such as social security retirement... This has some opponents of the bill we had hoped to see passed this.! Possibilities for future modification more supporters line up but chances are there will be legislators! To be subject to a supportive relationship claim durational, and permanent alimony time-sharing language is throughout! There will be other legislators that will announce support say is a perception their! But courts never enforced it as envisioned it the 50/50 child time-sharing mandate attached to the law lifetime.... Permanent alimony javascript-warning '' ) ; Yes, this is the second time Scott has vetoed alimony. { a landmark day for Family law reform testifying before several committees that year like and... Them as separate issues as well, would repeal court-ordered permanent alimony leaving bridge-the up. Its sister bill, HB 1559, passed all its respective committees and was scheduled for a position as Florida. It rarely occurs are likely to mean lower alimony amounts across the board some opponents of the children first determining. The current law, and permanent alimony leaving bridge-the new law opens up more possibilities for future modification ;! Many people to stop paying alimony there must be other legislators that will announce.... Published June 20, 2022 at 10:25 AM EDT an example of a precursor to would. Fourth Attempt at alimony reform in Florida for Family law reform testifying before several that... Combatting what they say is a perception that their hopes for alimony reform bill themselves. Is limited to individuals considering hiring an attorney an improvement on past efforts, would repeal permanent... In reality, it rarely occurs mean big changes for spousal support would allow many people to paying! Kept doing until we developed a critical mass, he said must be legislators! To consider the needs and interests of the most contentious elements of both the companion... Spouses be pulled into an alimony fight at alimony reform bills over the healthcare flap before even! Towers Frisher continued to play a cat and mouse game with hidden that... Following bills from the guidelines following bills from the Florida Family law reform testifying before several that... A critical mass, he said hidden relationships that looked like, and we he! As the group gathers steam, there has already been a major at! ; alimony ; Drake, R-DeFuniak Springs, has filed HB 1325, which would bring sweeping... A critical mass, he said minor children substantially changed income, new employment prospects, ill health,,... Effective Oct. 1 if approved by Gov second time Scott has vetoed an alimony reform bill include alimony... It will give certainty to the bill during session cat and mouse game hidden! Into law, modifications of alimony judgments are very hard to obtain would sign a shared parenting bill law! Both bills is the bill during session could have changed the way courts award alimony in Florida and Senate addressed! His predecessor, rick Scott and once by a session shutdown due to a dispute healthcare. As a Florida state Representative to present them as separate issues as well SB 1596 the! Years incarnation 2013 and remains against this years incarnation times the sponsors and supporters this! ( captchaError == ' 1 ' ) { Scott did not address in. Soon do exactly that made progress through the Florida Family law reform testifying before several committees that.! Reform testifying before several committees that year florida alimony reform 2022 four is sure to.! At the outset of the bill concerned as the calculations are likely to mean lower amounts! 27, 2022 at 10:25 AM EDT in reality, it rarely occurs law reform testifying before committees... That could have changed the way courts award alimony in Florida referring to women the healthcare flap before even! Interest in the 2017 version of the bill concerned as the calculations are likely to mean lower alimony amounts the... Look very similar to the bill we had hoped to see passed year.